To tell you the truth, even writing this blog, it feels gross and like something that we should not have to learn and teach and be prepared for. We want to trust our health care providers. We want to believe that they want the best for us, based on what we want for our own bodies. Right?
Um, right?
But here is the truth: not everything a doctor or nurse says to a birthing person is accurate. Some of it is outdated. Some of it is exaggerated. Most is practice-based and challenges the evidence and guidelines. Some of it is phrased in a way that is designed, consciously or not, to get compliance rather than genuine informed consent. And some of it is just flipping wrong.
This does not mean every provider is malicious. Most are not. But the system that trained them, the routines they operate within, and the pressures they work under create conditions where a birthing person’s autonomy can get slowly eroded without anyone in the room fully realizing it is happening.
As a doula, this is one of the hardest things to navigate. As a pregnant person, it is one of the most important things to understand before you walk through those hospital doors. For real!
Why this happens: ethical fading and the routine problem
There is a concept called ethical fading, and once you understand it, so much of what happens in birth spaces starts to make sense.
Ethical fading is what happens when repeated routine causes a person to stop seeing the ethical weight of what they are doing. When something is done hundreds of times, it stops feeling like a decision and starts feeling like just the way things are done. The ethical question fades into the background.
This is how a nurse can insert an IV, break someone’s waters, or perform a cervical check without explicit consent and genuinely not see a problem with it. They would be horrified if you asked them directly whether they do things without patient consent. But the routine has made it invisible to them.
For birthing people this matters enormously because consent is not a one-time thing and it is not implied. A provider needs to explain what they are doing and why, and get a yes, every single time. Even if they asked an hour ago and the answer was yes, they need to ask again.
Routine does not erase the need for consent and yet in birth spaces it does, constantly.
The language that moves people without them noticing
The other piece of this is language, and it is worth knowing the patterns because they come up in almost every hospital birth.
The first one is those four little words: “I’m just going to…”
“I’m just going to check your cervix.”
“I’m just going to pop your waters.”
“I’m just going to add something to your IV.”
The word “just” does enormous work here. It minimizes. It makes the thing sound small, quick, not worth questioning. It moves the person from decision maker to passive recipient before they have had a chance to say yes or no.
This is how procedures happen without consent while the provider genuinely believes consent was given.
Then there is hyperbole, which works in the opposite direction. Where “just” makes things seem small, hyperbole makes things seem urgent and scary.
“Your placenta is aging.”
“The baby is in trouble.”
“You’re failing to progress.”
“This is becoming an emergency.”
“That is unsafe and risky.”
These phrases create fear. Fear moves people toward compliance faster than almost anything else. A provider who says something is “unsafe” can erase a birth preference that took months to build in about thirty seconds. It does not matter whether the claim is accurate. The emotional weight of it lands first and the critical thinking comes later, if at all.
Some other common ones worth knowing:
“We’ll give you an hour to progress.” Who decided an hour? Based on what guidelines?
“I can’t deliver the baby from there.” This is almost never literally true. It usually means it is less convenient from where they are standing.
“You’re not allowed to do that.” Allowed by whom? This is a hospital, not a prison. Birthing people have rights.
“We just want to make sure everyone goes home healthy.” This sounds caring. It is often used to shut down questions.
“Don’t worry, none of the medication will get to the baby.” This is simply not accurate. Epidural medication does cross to the baby. Saying it does not is not an opinion, it is incorrect information.
This is what medical coercion sounds like in practice, and sadly, we hear this at every single birth we attend in the hospital. Not necessarily this script, but versions of it as well as ethical fading.
View this post on Instagram
Why even experienced doulas freeze with medical coercion in birth
Bianca, the founder of bebo mia, has been doing birth work for nearly 20 years. She wrote recently about that yuck stomach feeling when something is said in the room that is not right but she cannot put her finger on exactly why fast enough. The client looks at her. She smiles back hoping it will prompt them to ask questions they practiced in prenatals. Sometimes they take the smile as agreement and nod yes.
That moment, she says, is when she feels like she has let her client down.
This is not a beginner problem. It is a real time problem. Knowing your evidence in a classroom is completely different from accessing it in seconds at 4am in hour eighteen of a labor while managing a scared client and a provider who just shifted the energy in the room.
The brain under stress does not perform at its best. Doubt creeps in. As a society we have been conditioned to trust doctors, to believe they are there to help, to assume they would not say something untrue. That conditioning does not just switch off because you completed doula training.
We wrote more about this dynamic in our blog on medical coercion in birth spaces and you can check it out here.
What the research says about how common medical coercion in birth is
The Giving Voice to Mothers study found that one in six birthing people in the United States experienced mistreatment during maternity care. The Birthrights End Coercion in Maternity Care report found systematic coercive practices in UK maternity services. Research consistently shows that BIPOC birthing people, Indigenous birthing people, fat birthing people, and those with mental health histories face disproportionately higher rates of coercion and mistreatment.
This is not occasional. This is systemic. And it is happening in rooms where doulas are present right now without the tools to name it fast enough.
What birth doulas and birth mates can do in the moment
The BRAIN framework is a good starting point. Before agreeing to anything, ask about Benefits, Risks, Alternatives, what your Intuition is saying, and what happens if you do Nothing. This slows the moment down and gives the birthing person space to actually make a decision.
Asking the provider to write their recommendation down, or asking for their source, also changes the dynamic significantly. Documented recommendations tend to be more careful ones over verbal citations.
But honestly, these strategies require you to be sharp, calm, and quick in a moment when you are probably none of those things. This is exactly why we built a tool specifically for this problem.
The Evidence or Coercion? Birth Truth Tool™
Evidence or Coercion? Birth Truth Tool™ is a real-time advocacy tool built for birth doulas, doulas in training, and birth mates who want to be ready before they need to be ready.
You type in what the provider just said, or tap the closest topic from the prenatal, labor and birth, or after birth tabs. The tool immediately tells you whether the phrase is evidence-based or a documented coercion pattern, what level of concern it represents, what current guidelines actually say, and gives you ready-made scripts for what to say to the provider, what to say to your client, and what to document.
It covers more than 50 topics. Citations adjust based on your country, Canada uses SOGC guidelines, the US uses ACOG, the UK uses NICE. It includes an equity lens for 11 identity and experience categories, a Doula Under Attack button for when your role is being undermined, and an incident report with jurisdiction-specific contacts.
No app, no download. It lives on a page, works on any device, and can be open in the birth space without anyone knowing what it is.
It is currently at beta pricing of $39, the lowest it will ever be. When beta closes the price goes to $79. Every purchase includes the In-the-Moment Advocacy Card, a printable three-page reference with 130 plus documented coercive phrases, the BRAIN framework, and ready-made scripts for your birth bag.
Be ready for medical coercion and check it out here.
One last thing about medical coercion
If you are a pregnant person reading this, please know that you have the right to say no to anything in your birth space. You have the right to ask questions. You have the right to time to think. No one can do anything to your body without your consent, including the things that get framed as routine.
And if you are a doula reading this, the shame of missing a moment of coercion is real. Bianca feels it too sometimes. The answer is not more shame, it is better tools.
Because your clients deserve a doula who knows the difference between evidence and pressure.
If you would like to explore becoming a doula, reach out and we can discuss doula training options with you… we love to chat so much! Email us at [email protected] to find out about our live online doula training certifications.
FREE ONLINE MINI-COURSE
BLISS IN BUSINESS RETREAT
Your future is created by what you do today — that's why we created a completely FREE mindset mini-course to help doulas and birth workers find bliss in their business!