What Happens When a Doula Makes a Mistake?

PIN IT

This question comes up a lot from people who are considering doula training and it usually comes from a specific fear. The fear of saying the wrong thing. Of giving bad advice. Of being responsible for a decision that goes badly.

And before we go anywhere else, let’s address that fear because it is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what doulas actually do.

Doulas are a resource, never a source.

That distinction is everything, babes. 

A doula does not tell clients what to do. A doula does not share their personal opinion about what choice someone should make. A doula does not advise, diagnose, or recommend a course of action. 

What a doula does is help clients access information, ask better questions, and make their own fully informed decisions. The decision always belongs to the client.

This means the category of mistake most people are afraid of, telling someone to do the wrong thing and causing harm, is not actually available to a doula who is working within their scope. 

You are not the source of the decision. You are a support for the person making it.

That said, doulas are human and humans make mistakes. Here is an honest look at what those actually are and what to do about them.

Mistakes with pronouns, names, and identity

This is one of the most common real mistakes doulas make and one of the most important to handle directly, swiftly, and responsibly.

You might use the wrong pronoun for a client or their partner. You might use a client’s deadname by accident. You might slip into gendered language out of habit when your client has asked you to use neutral language.

When this happens, correct it the same way you would if you stepped on someone’s foot in the grocery store. Make eye contact, apologize genuinely and briefly, correct yourself, and move on. A short sincere acknowledgment followed by getting it right is what people need. A lengthy, elaborate apology that centers your own distress about the mistake does not actually serve the person you got wrong.

The thing that genuinely harms people is not the initial mistake. It is the repeated mistake. It signals that you did not care enough to adjust. So make a note, build the correct language into your practice, and do not let it happen again.

PIN IT

Mistakes in physical support

Some mistakes in the physical support category are genuinely low stakes and pretty nuanced. For example, you might suggest a position change that does not end up being the most helpful option for where the baby is sitting. You might try a comfort measure that does not land well for a particular client.

These are normal parts of learning and practicing. Birth is not a standardized process and what works beautifully for one client can feel wrong to another. Good training helps you build a broad enough toolkit that you can pivot quickly when something is not working. 

The mistake is rarely the problem. Getting stuck on it or not reading the room and adjusting is where it gets harder.

Mistakes in observation and referral

Here is where scope of practice becomes really important.

A doula is not a clinician. You are not diagnosing, assessing, or treating anything. So if you miss that a postpartum client is developing mastitis, you have not made a clinical error because diagnosing mastitis is not your job. What is your job is noticing that something seems off and making a strong referral to someone who can assess it properly. An IBCLC, a doctor, a midwife.

The mistake doulas sometimes make here is not in failing to catch a clinical issue. It is in not referring out when the signs are pointing somewhere beyond their scope. Trying to support something that needs professional clinical attention because you want to be helpful is how doulas accidentally work outside their lane.

Know what belongs to you and know what belongs to someone else: a therapist, an IBCLC, a pelvic floor physiotherapist, a doctor. Building strong referral relationships means your clients always have somewhere to go when they need more than you can offer.

PIN IT

Mistakes in reading client fit

Every experienced doula has at least one story of a client relationship that was not a good fit and went on longer than it should have. Yikes, they feel so, so bad when this happens. 

Bianca, the founder of bebo mia, remembers having a client that was so toxic and high needs she felt anxious and depressed until the client was wrapped up and the file was closed. Bianca adds, “It was a long 7 months working with her, I wanted to give her a refund and tell her to never call me again around week 39, but I did not know how. And then years after her birth happened, she sent a wildly rude email about my care. It was the cherry on the nightmare sundae!”

Sometimes the signs are there early that this is not the right match, values are misaligned, communication is consistently difficult, the client is asking you to do things outside your scope, or the dynamic is draining in a way that does not resolve. And instead of having the honest conversation about fit, the doula keeps going because firing a client feels terrible.

Not firing a client when all the signs are pointing that direction is a mistake. 

It is not good for you and it is honestly not good for them either. A client deserves a doula who can be genuinely present for them and if that is not possible in this particular relationship, the kind thing is to say so and help them find someone who is a better fit.

Mistakes in pricing and contracts

We have a lot of content about this in our pricing blogs and podcast episodes but the short version is that undercharging, not having a clear contract, not including a backup clause, and not protecting your time and labour properly are all mistakes that cost doulas significantly over time.

These are fixable business mistakes and they almost always come from training that skipped the business side entirely. Which is exactly why we build it into our full spectrum doula training at bebo mia rather than treating it as an optional add-on.

PIN IT

What to do when you make a mistake

Acknowledge it. Keep the acknowledgment proportionate to the size of the mistake. Correct course. Learn from it. And then put it down (this last part can be easier said than done).

The inner critic will be loudest when you are tired and depleted and it will try to turn a normal human mistake into evidence that you are not cut out for this work. It is almost never right about that. The doulas who do this work well over time are not the ones who never make mistakes. They are the ones who handle mistakes with honesty, repair them without drama, and build systems that prevent the same mistake from happening again.

If something happens at a birth that leaves you genuinely unsure whether you handled it correctly, that is what mentorship and peer debrief are for. Talk it through with someone who gets the work. The point of this is not to assign blame and it can feel uncomfortable. The goal is to understand what you might do differently next time.

That is how you grow as a doula. 

It is not about being perfect, but about being honest and curious and willing to learn.

If you want training that prepares you for the real complexity of this work, including scope of practice, referral systems, how to handle difficult dynamics, and how to build a sustainable practice that protects both you and your clients, our full spectrum doula training runs every March and September.

Already certified and feel like some of this was missing from what you learned? The cert transfer program is here.

And if you want to talk through what doula work actually looks like in practice, book a free doula career strategy session or email us at [email protected].